Last updated September 19, 2026 · ranked from 3,063 Google reviews · How we rank
Sandwich choices in Plymouth, MI range from daytime deli stops to grilled subs and late-evening sliders. Maya’s Deli at 550 Forest Ave #2 has the highest Google rating among the Plymouth, MI addresses in this guide: 4.8 stars from 285 reviews. Reviewers praise its fresh sandwich ingredients, basil pesto, and gluten-free bun. Its hours favor lunch, with a 4 p.m. weekday closing and a 3:30 p.m. Saturday closing.
For longer daily hours, Jersey Mike’s Subs at 1500 S Sheldon Rd and Firehouse Subs at 41608 Ann Arbor Rd both open from 10 a.m. to 9 p.m. Jersey Mike’s holds 4.3 stars from 266 reviews and serves cold-cut subs; Firehouse has 4.2 stars from 549 reviews and offers made-to-order hot and cold subs. Penn Station at 44431 Ann Arbor Rd focuses on grilled subs, fries, and fresh-squeezed lemonade, closing at 10 p.m. Monday through Saturday.
Two other choices share a 4.4-star rating: Detroit Ham & Corned Beef Co. on Five Mile Rd has 422 reviews, while Grand Traverse Pie Company on Ann Arbor Rd has 961. The latter adds sweet and savory pies, a fireplace, and outdoor seating. For sliders rather than full-size subs, Savvy Sliders at 560 Ann Arbor Rd serves beef, chicken, ribeye, and falafel versions, with Friday and Saturday hours extending to 11 p.m.
Top picks at a glance
1Maya's DeliReviews praise Maya's Deli for fresh ingredients, basil pesto, and a gluten-free bun.
2Grand Traverse Pie CompanyGrand Traverse Pie Company offers classic cafe fare, sweet and savory pies, and a quiet dining room with a fireplace.
3Detroit Ham & Corned Beef Co.Detroit Ham & Corned Beef Co. offers counter service, takeout, and delivery Monday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to 7 p.m.
4.8(285)· Google4.8 out of 5 from 285 reviews (Google rating)
Sandwich · $$ · Downtown Plymouth / Kellogg Park
Closed today
Fresh ingredients, basil pesto, and a gluten-free bun receive specific praise in reviews of Maya's Deli, giving its first-place ranking a foundation beyond convenience. The sandwich shop at 550 Forest Ave #2 in Plymouth, MI holds a 4.8 Google rating across 285 reviews. Other reviewers praise the sandwiches and friendly service, with one reporting repeat visits whenever they're nearby. Dine-in, takeout, and delivery accommodate different lunch plans, while free lot and street parking make pickup practical.
4.4(961)· Google4.4 out of 5 from 961 reviews (Google rating)
Restaurant · $$ · Sheldon Road corridor
Closed · opens 9:00 AM
A quiet dining room with a fireplace and options beyond lunch help Grand Traverse Pie Company earn the No. 2 spot. This sandwich shop at 41640 Ann Arbor Rd in Plymouth, MI pairs classic cafe fare with sweet and savory pies, plus vegetarian and healthier choices. Its Google rating is 4.4 from 961 reviews, and the supplied reviews praise a lunch and the quiet setting. Counter service, takeout, delivery, and free parking add practical reasons to visit.
Sweet and savory pies
Quiet fireplace setting
Vegetarian options
“Had a great lunch! The pie was of course was amazing and also had the roast beef pot pie!”
4.4(422)· Google4.4 out of 5 from 422 reviews (Google rating)
Sandwich · $$ · Plymouth Township West (Beck & North Territorial)
Closed today
Counter service, a quiet setting, and breakfast-through-dinner hours put Detroit Ham & Corned Beef Co. at No. 3. This sandwich shop at 47287 Five Mile Rd in Plymouth, MI holds a 4.4-star Google rating from 422 reviews. Open Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 7 p.m., it offers seating, takeout, and delivery, with lunch and dinner among its popular uses. Free lot and street parking add convenience, while catering provides an option for group orders.
4.2(549)· Google4.2 out of 5 from 549 reviews (Google rating)
Sandwich · $ · Sheldon Road corridor
Open now · closes 9:00 PM
Made-to-order hot and cold subs, a variety of hot sauces, and daily 10 a.m.–9 p.m. hours put Firehouse Subs Plymouth Town Center at No. 4. This counter-service shop at 41608 Ann Arbor Rd in Plymouth, MI holds a 4.2-star Google rating from 549 reviews. One reviewer reported that all eight diners enjoyed their subs and praised the gluten-free buns. Vegetarian options, a children’s menu, free parking, and curbside pickup add practical reasons to stop for lunch or dinner.
Hot and cold subs
Daily lunch and dinner
Free parking
“They gave me the wrong size sub and I called to get the error fixed. The manager was rude and incompetent. I was told to order a large next time and they were not willing to help me. I’ve ordered multiple times for firehouse and I KNOW m…”
4.3(10)· Google4.3 out of 5 from 10 reviews (Google rating)
Sandwich · $$ · Ann Arbor Road corridor
Cut-to-order meats and a pre-sliced selection help Kroger Deli earn the No. 5 spot. At 44525 Ann Arbor Rd in Plymouth, MI, the counter offers handcrafted sandwiches, freshly sliced meats and cheeses, salads, and prepared sides. Reviewers praise the meat selection, friendly employees, and fast service, with one specifically appreciating the pre-sliced area. Takeout, delivery, and in-store pickup add practical options for getting a meal, while party platters cover larger gatherings. Its Google rating is 4.3 from 10 reviews.
Handcrafted sandwiches
Cut-to-order meats
In-store pickup
“They are the nicest deli counter at any store, fresh meat, great employees”
3.9(503)· Google3.9 out of 5 from 503 reviews (Google rating)
Sandwich · $$ · Ann Arbor Road corridor
Open now · closes 9:00 PM
Grilled subs, fries, and fresh-squeezed lemonade give Penn Station Sandwiches a focused menu at 44431 Ann Arbor Rd in Plymouth, MI. It earns the No. 6 spot with that sandwich-centered offering, vegetarian options, and several ways to order: counter service, takeout, and delivery. The casual dining room accommodates solo lunches and group meals, while a children’s menu and high chairs serve families. Free lot and street parking add convenience. Its Google rating is 3.9 out of 5 from 503 reviews.
Grilled sub sandwiches
Fresh-squeezed lemonade
Vegetarian options
“Workers ignoring people with the door locked almost an hour before closing”
3.6(333)· Google3.6 out of 5 from 333 reviews (Google rating)
Bakery · $$ · Plymouth Township West (Beck & North Territorial)
Open now · closes 9:00 PM
Long daily hours and several ways to order earn Panera Bread its No. 7 spot. At 47411 Five Mile Rd in Plymouth, MI, this counter-service bakery and cafe serves sandwiches alongside salads, with vegetarian and vegan options on the menu. Takeout, drive-through service, and delivery offer alternatives to dining in, while a fireplace and free WiFi support a sit-down lunch. One reviewer enjoyed a luncheon meeting, and another praised the food; its 3.6-star rating from 333 reviews reflects a mixed overall response.
Drive-through and delivery
Vegetarian and vegan options
Fireplace and WiFi
“Drive-through service was horrible. I’m OK with waiting as long as I’m communicated to .Mercedes has a nasty attitude never greeted me properly. Didn’t ask me how I wanted my food items and decided for me and the food was for my daughter…”
Map of every pick
Compare at a glance
Comparison of the best Sandwich Shops in Plymouth, MI
3.6(333)3.6 out of 5 from 333 reviews (Google rating)
$$
Plymouth Township West (Beck & North Territorial)
Open
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each sandwich shop is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Plymouth category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Which sandwich stop has the highest Google rating in Plymouth, MI?
Maya’s Deli at 550 Forest Ave #2 leads the Plymouth, MI entries with 4.8 stars from 285 reviews. It offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery, plus free lot and street parking.
Where can I get sandwiches later in the evening in Plymouth, MI?
Penn Station at 44431 Ann Arbor Rd lists hours until 10 p.m. Monday through Saturday and 9 p.m. Sunday. Savvy Sliders at 560 Ann Arbor Rd closes at 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday, 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday, and 9 p.m. Sunday. Jersey Mike’s and Firehouse Subs both close at 9 p.m. daily.
Which places offer vegetarian or vegan choices in Plymouth, MI?
Savvy Sliders offers a vegetarian falafel slider and describes its lettuce-wrapped falafel version as vegan. Panera Bread at 47411 Five Mile Rd lists vegan and vegetarian options. Firehouse Subs, Jersey Mike’s, Penn Station, Subway, and Grand Traverse Pie Company also list vegetarian offerings.
Where are gluten-free sandwich buns mentioned in Plymouth, MI?
A Maya’s Deli reviewer specifically praises the gluten-free bun. A Firehouse Subs reviewer also praises gluten-free sub buns at its 41608 Ann Arbor Rd location. These are customer reports about the buns, not statements about kitchen allergen practices.
Which sandwich places offer catering in Plymouth, MI?
Firehouse Subs, Penn Station, Jersey Mike’s, Subway, Detroit Ham & Corned Beef Co., Panera Bread, Grand Traverse Pie Company, and Savvy Sliders all list catering. For individual pickup orders, Firehouse Subs and Subway also offer curbside pickup.
1
